I’m your nerd host, Chris Hardwick
Nerdist is a place where we nerds come together and share the nerdery that we find. It's also my home to various elements of the Nerdist Empire. You might recognize me from TV. You don't realize that's where you know me from, but it is. You think you went to college with me or I look like your cousin's friend, but that is not the case. At one time or another you stumbled upon me on your moving picture box in such cerebral gems as MTV's "Singled Out" and Noam Chomsky's "Shipmates." and so much more...


Finally! Something that’ll get me to sit through Star Trek from the beginning. (I can spend an eternity swimming in Capt. Pike’s eyes….)
“Tango.” The horse’s name is “Tango.”
Great job! Good discussion, and fun to listen to. I’m excited to re-watch the series along with the podcast.
But please, please, please, ditch the Siri voice. It’s embarrassing.
+1 for ditching the machine read voice. It doesn’t add anything and IMO detracts from the experience
Dude! So glad this is coming out! When I heard about it, for some reason it had a “distant future” vibe to it. I am SO excited to watch the entirety of Star Trek this way. BOOM!
…I say “BOOM!” sometimes.
My grandmother was Jeffrey Hunter’s “High School Sweetheart”…If only that had worked out…
I have a question. Has anyone ever brought up the similarities between the Talosians illusions and the holodeck in TNG?
This is very cool. I’m looking forward to next week.
Jooooooooooooooooooooooy!!!!!!
Having a Trek podcast without the brain of Matt Mira is a MAJOR disservice to Trek fans.
Yes, lose the computer voice. I’ve never been a huge Treki (Trekki? -Y?), but really enjoyed listening to articulate people discuss this. Great job.
dont let any naysayers keep you down, this is a wonderful concept,since there is no new(or at least any good) star trek they least we as trekkies can do is sit back down,revisit every wonderful,and not so wonderful episode. Ill be listening every week, keep it up!!!
Great first podcast, guys. I learned a lot (had no ideal Spoke was originally supposed to be British and red…that’s just crazy)
Good podcast! I love listening to thoughts on the OS… but could we get a nicer robot voice for the segment titles?
Agree on the ditching Siri.
I don’t think it’s the Siri voice. I think it’s just a generic voice that comes with text-to-speech software. (Siri would be a step up from this voice.)
Listening to this dialog makes me wish that Gene Roddenberry could appear the way Marshall McLuhan appeared out of nowhere in the move Annie Hall.
One of the good things about Star Trek is that you can have these kinds of discussions, ranging from TV culture to race to how religion was portrayed in the 60s versus now. Good job on this first episode, and I look forward to listening to more.
They had me at…Log
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH…………the sharp S’s hurt! need Some cotton to Soften the Sudden piercing Sounds! Great Show though
i love this, just finished watching all of star trek tv shows begining to end(?). it took quite awhile. i don’t believe the religious implacations of heaven and hell would have been that big of deal until the late 70′s and the start the “religous right”.
Great first podcast and an additional thought: there’s a line that caught my attention when the doc is talking to Pike over drinks. He says something like “A man will tell his bartender things he wouldn’t even tell his doctor”. I wonder if this line or this idea ended up being the inspiration for Guinan in TNG. Just a thought.
Can’t wait. Will it be available through Stitcher? I sure hope so.
Nicely done. Congratulations! I will defiantly make this a regular listen. I too saw “The Cage” when Gene was traveling the country and I was most impressed. One thing that I did like was how much of the original pilot survived in the making of “The Menagerie”, not too many story points were lost.
Another carry over from this first pilot to STNG, in addition to the first office “Number One” monicker was the order “Engage” from the captain to “set sail” so to speak.
Also I was impressed by your analogy to TV watching and its increasing voyeuristic nature, I never saw the Talosions (SP?) as being hooked on their monitors, I always thought they experienced their specimen’s thought inside their heads. I thought the monitor was only a visual provided to show the audience that Pike and company were being watched.
Looking forward to following this. Just do like everyone else is saying and get rid of the computer voice.
I always thought that the movie Generations took a litte inspiration from The Cage. Basically your deepest fantasy coming to life.
Great first podcast, and thank you for starting with The Cage. It’s one of my favorite episodes. Out of curiosity, did you guys decide right away you would go through the broadcast order of the show, or did you at all consider using the production order? Since the second pilot, Where No Man Has Gone Before, would’ve been next, I hope we’ll hear an analysis of the different approaches each pilot took in presenting the concept of the show.
I’ll be tuning in next week!
This was so good. Intelligently an entertainingly discussed. I really enjoyed this and am looking forward to more. Thanks for this, Nerdist! I would like to learn a bit more about our hosts, and look forward to that. Will there be guests? I know Matt Mira would be a great occasional inclusion.
And a thought on the hate for the robot voice – I kind of like it as segment bumpers but agree the voice itself could be nicer. What about Katie Levine, who does so much other wonderful work on the Nerdist podcasts? Or mystery celebrity guest bumpers! Don’t reveal the identity until the end so we can guess the voices!
You should link up with Rob at everystartrekever.com! He’s been doing a killer job blogging his way through, well, every Star Trek ever.
As much as I love good Trek, I’m looking forward to the discussion of the worst episodes even more. Spread the Bij.
Is weekly even doable? I appreciate the goal, but with THAT many episodes, it will take like 13 YEARS
Brilliant show! I love the discussion, and am looking forward to more! Keep it coming!
Great episode guys, thanks a billion.
Your thought about “The Cage” having a frontier/Western feel to it is not far off. Recall that Gene Roddenberry’s concept of Star Trek was “Wagon Train to the Stars” (http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/WagonTrainToTheStars)
Also, as to your idea that themes in this pilot appear later in the Star Trek Universe, I offer this one: Pike’s decision to rescue or ignore a distress call is quite similar to the Kobayashi Maru scenario.
Thanks again.
Hey guys, great job on the debut podcast! As an old-skool Trekker (not Trekkie), I will definitely be keeping up with the show.
I’m actually surprised you didn’t cover this, but in Gene’s original script (or at least the original outline, I forget where it changed), the Talosians were squat, crab-like creatures with no resemblence to a human being at all. At a certain point it became obvious that this was going to be prohibitively expensive to film, and the Keepers were switched to the humanoids we now know and love. This is obviously the basis for the “we had no idea how to put her back together” bit with Vina, a holdover from the original script that does end up looking a little silly.
Thankyou for doing this show!
I’ve been going back after each podcast and watching the shows on streaming (I’m using amazon prime, pretty sure its on netflix too).
I actually never watched the original series, I’m really enjoying your episode analysis
Anyways I’m loving it, thanks guys keep up the awesome work
I have never watched a star trek episode all the way through but I am loving your podcast.
You should have Robert Meyer Burnett as a guest on one of these podcast.
I actually originally didn’t realize this was from its own pilot episode. I originally viewed the The Menagerie, which I thought was very in-depth history containing its Captain Pike story line. It wasn’t until later when I actually realized my error from internet lore, and went back to watch “The Cage”. To be honest though, I liked “The Menagerie” re-visiting that timeline than I cared for “The Cage” episode. The ending of “The Menagerie” was touching, and the story pretty great as far as developing the star trek’s infant universe.
I really loved the early analysis on Spock’s character, because imagine Spock’s storyline being depicted in this early year of his star fleet service. Spock whom you get to follow through different generations and mediums of the startrek universe has his character lightly undefined at this point, and even so they use this early episode to depict him as an extremely loyal first officer. Also the comments of the sampling of ST-TNG concepts taken from OST is well pointed out with the LCAR computer and many other concepts TNG uses to bridges two series very well.
But, i could go on all day about this
I can’t be the only one to notice the similarity between the odd, pop up displays on the bridge of the Enterprise in this episode and the heat ray guns on the Martian ships in The War of the Worlds (1953). Tip of the hat to prior SciFi?
http://i.imgur.com/o1aoq.jpg
Super late to the game here, but really awesome guys! You’ve now got a friend in me
.